5681 NY-28, Phoenicia, NY 12464 (845) 688-9957
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

MENUS

  • Gallery Slide 1
    Slide 1 of 8
  • Gallery Slide 2
    Slide 2 of 8
  • Gallery Slide 3
    Slide 3 of 8
  • Gallery Slide 4
    Slide 4 of 8
  • Gallery Slide 5
    Slide 5 of 8
  • a plate of food
    Slide 6 of 8
  • a close up of a sandwich on a plate
    Slide 7 of 8
  • a plate of food on a table
    Slide 8 of 8

    • 1st Course

    • Lexical Amaro Margarita

      herradura reposado, lexical amaro, fresh lime, agave

    • Bushburg Pilsner

      100% pilsner malt, german lager yeast, noble hop varieties noble aroma, herbal minty noble hop character bright taste, slightly sweet, dry grassy finish

    • Flor de Sandía

      hibiscus, watermelon, limeade

    • Charred Tomato & Shrimp Tostada

    • Mini Corn & Crab Cakes

    2nd Course

    • Fest Bier Lager

      all-german, pils, vienna, and munich malts, saaz, saphir, and tettnang hops

    • Sober Oktober

      tuk tuk chai, lemon juice, spicy ginger beer

    • Lager Steamed Clams

      heriloom tomato, garlic scapes, arborio bread

    3rd Course

    • Premier IPA

      tropical & citrus aromas, taste of bubblegum, melon, pineapple, light, refreshing, crisp finish

    • Babet's Lament

      fresh lemon juice, simple, peach, lavender, seltzer

    • Wood Grilled Pork Chop

      smoked cheddar grits, IPA pickled peaches

    Dessert

    • Single Malted Milkshake

      straight malt whiskey, ronny brook vanilla ice cream, malted milk served alongside a sample of malt whiskey

    • Vanilla Malted

      for our mocktail tickets; ronny brook vanilla ice cream, malted milk

    Locally Sourced When Possible | Served All Day | Housemade Bread

    • Housemade Granola | 8

      fresh fruit, yogurt

    • Locally Smoked Trout or Lox on A Bagel | 12

      scallion cream cheese, red onion, capers on a Brooklyn bagel

    • Egg & Cheese on A Roll | 6

      w/ Phoenician potatoes

      add ham, bacon, pork or turkey sausage + $4

    • Buttermilk or Buckwheat Pancakes | 12

      fresh fruit, local maple syrup

    • French Toast | 11

      fresh fruit, local maple syrup (10)

    • Breakfast Burrito | 10

      scrambled eggs, cheddar, avocado mash, phoenician potatoes , flour tortilla, salsa verde, served w/refried beans

      Bacon $3

    • Eggs Any Way | 9

      bacon or sausage, Phoenician potatoes, toast

    • Omelet Your Way | 12

      phoenician potatoes, toast choose up to 3 items, swiss, cheddar, feta, goat cheese, spinach, tomato, onion, peppers, mushroom, bacon, sausage, ham

      each addt’l item $2

    • Full Phoenicia Breakfast | 13

      two eggs anyway, sausage, bacon, baked beans, grilled tomatoes, phoenician potatoes, toast

    • Avocado Street Corn Toast | 11

      avocado mash, soft poached egg, sweet corn, lime tofu, heirloom tomato, farmers cheese, sourdough

      Trout $5

      Salmon $5

    Skillets

    • Arnold Bennett Skillet | 14

      scrambled eggs, locally smoked trout, parmesan cheese, chives, crème fraîche

    • Taco Skillet | 12

      scrambled eggs, chorizo, crispy corn tortilla, pico de gallo, crema, refried beans, salsa verde, queso fresco

    • Farmers’ Skillet | 11

      market vegetables, onions, phoenician potatoes, cheddar, two eggs any way, toast

      bacon $2

    • Corned Beef Skillet | 13

      house cured grass fed brisket, onions, peppers, phoenician potatoes, two poached eggs

    Sides

    • Steel Cut Oatmeal

      Cup $4

      Bowl $6

    • Fresh Fruit | 5

    • Phoenician Potatoes | 5

    • Cheddar Grits | 3

    • Bacon, Pork Sausage, Turkey Sausage Patty | 4

    • Side Salad | 5

    • Seasonal Vegetables | 5

    • House Cut Fries | 5

    • Beer Battered Onion Rings | 7

    • Mac & Cheese | 6

    • Local Maple Syrup | 1.5

    We serve Mimosas, Bloody Marys, Bourbon Milkshakes, Wine, Beer & Cocktails | 

    Sandwiches

    served w/ house cut fries or mixed greens

    • Avocado Street Corn Toast | 11

      avocado mash, soft poached egg, sweet corn, lime tofu, heirloom tomato, farmers cheese, sourdough

      locally smoked trout or lox $5

    • Chorizo Sandwich | 15

      house-made chorizo, ny cheddar, egg, green onions, lettuce, tomato, pickled jalapeño remoulade, brioche

    • The Mitchell Tuna Melt | 14

      line caught tuna, mayo, fines herbes, wasabi tobiko, potato chips, lettuce, tomato, onion, wheat bread

    • Scuttlebutt | 14

      pickled beets & carrots, hard boiled egg, herb salad, pimenton aioli, focaccia

    • Catskills PoBoy | 16

      cornmeal crusted trout, remoulade, tomato, shredded lettuce, french baguette

    • Classic Turkey Club | 15

      roasted turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, toasted whole wheat

    • Reuben | 14

      house cured corned beef, swiss cheese, sauerkraut and Russian dressing on rye

    • Spicy Chicken Sandwich | 14

      buffalo chicken, sour cream & onion dip, lettuce, tomato, onion, brioche

      Bacon $3

    • Grass Fed Burger | 14

      lettuce, tomato, housemade brioche roll

      cheese + $1

      bacon + $2

    • Pimento Bacon Burger | 16

      pastured beef, pimento cheese, bacon, pickles, lettuce, tomato, onion, brioche

    Soups

    • Tortilla Soup

      free range chicken, avocado, tortilla chips

      cup $5

      bowl $8

    • Soup of The Day

      cup $4

      bowl $7

    Salads

    • Greek Salad | 13

      feta, olives, pepperoncini, roasted peppers, dolmas, baby greens, house vinaigrette

      Chicken $4

      Smoked Trout $5

      Steelhead Trout $5

    • Spinach Salad | 11

      spinach, strawberries, rhubarb, walnuts, grapefruit poppyseed dressing

      Chicken $4

      Smoked Trout $5

      Steelhead Trout $5

    • Route 28 Cobb | 15

      mixed greens, hard-boiled egg, bacon, steelhead trout, chevre, sunflower seeds, pickled red onions, heirloom cherry tomatoes, red wine vinaigrette

      chicken $4

      Smoked Trout $5

    Platters

    • Hot Dog Mac & Cheese | 15

      local 100% beef dog, spinach, tomato, bacon, herbed breadcrumbs

    • Pan Fried Trout | 18

      local trout, garlic potatoes, market vegetables

    • Deconstructed Chicken Pot Pie | 15

      roasted chicken, herb pan gravy, carrots, celery, corn, potatoes, puff pastry

    Breakfast

    • Housemade Granola | 8

      fresh fruit, yogurt

    • Breakfast Burrito | 10

      scrambled eggs, cheddar, avocado mash, phoenician potatoes, pico de gallo, flour tortilla, salsa verde served w/ refried beans

      add chorizo $4

      add bacon $3

    • Egg & Cheese on A Roll | 6

      w/ phoenician potatoes

      add bacon, pork, or turkey sausage + $4

    • Locally Smoked Trout or Lox on A Bagel | 12

      scallion cream cheese, red onion, capers, Brooklyn bagel

    • Steel Cut Oatmeal | 6

      fresh fruit

    • Buttermilk Pancakes | 12

      fresh fruit, local maple syrup

    • Avocado Street Corn Toast

      avocado, soft poached egg, sweet corn, lime tofu, heirloom tomato, farmers cheese, sourdoug

      smoked trout $5

      lox $5

    • Arnold Skillet | 14

      scrambled eggs, locally smoked trout, parmesan, chives, creme fraiche, toast

    • Farmers Skillet | 13

      two eggs any way, potatoes, onions, market vegetables, ny cheddar, toast

      bacon $3

    Pastries

    • Muffin | 3

    • Cookies | 3.5

      fruition chocolate chunk oatmeal pecan

    • GF Coffee Cake | 4

    Soup

    • Tortilla Soup

      free range chicken, avocado, tortilla chips

      cup $5

      bowl $8

    • Soup of the Day

      cup $4

      bowl $7

    Beverages

    • Coffee

    • Iced Tea

    • Fresh Squeezed OJ

    • Fresh Squeezed Grapefruit

    • Apple Juice

    • Cranberry Juice

    • Coke

    • Diet Coke

    • Sprite

    • Gingerale

    • Root Beer

    Sides

    • French Fries

    • Phoenician Potatoes

    • Onion Rings

    • Side Salad

    • Bacon

    • Pork Sausage

    • Turkey Sausage

    • Mixed Berries

    • Fresh Fruit

    • Seasonal Veggies

    Lunch

    served w/ fries or greens

    • Avocado Street Corn Toast | 11

      avocado mash, soft poached egg, sweet corn, lime tofu, heirloom tomato, farmers cheese, sourdough

      add locally smoked trout or lox + $5

    • Chorizo Sandwich | 15

      house-made chorizo, ny cheddar egg, green onions, lettuce, tomato, pickled jalapeño remoulade, brioche

    • Pastured Burger | 14

      lettuce, tomato, housemade brioche roll

      add cheese + $1

      add bacon + $2

    • Crispy Chicken Sandwich | 14

      spicy chicken, sour cream & onion dip, lettuce, tomato, onion, brioche

      bacon $3

    • The Mitchell | 14

      line-caught albacore, mayo, wasabi tobiko, potato chips, lettuce, tomato, onion, wheat bread

    • Scuttlebutt | 14

      pickled beets & carrots, herb salad, hard boiled egg, pimenton aioli, focaccia

    Salads

    • Route 28 Cobb | 15

      mixed greens, hard-boiled egg, bacon, steelhead trout, chevre, sunflower seeds, pickled red onion, heirloom cherry tomatoes, red win vinaigrette

      Chicken $4

    • Spinach Salad | 11

      spinach, strawberries, rhubarb, walnuts grapefruit poppyseed dressing

      chicken $4

      Smoked Trout $5

      Steelhead Trou $5

    Under 12

    • Egg & Cheese Sandwich With Fruit | 7

    • Pancakes & Scrambled Egg | 7

    • Pasta with Cheese & Butter | 7

    • House-Made Tenders Nuggets with Fries | 7

    • Grilled Cheddar Cheese with Fries | 7

    • Kid's Grass Fed Burger on English Muffin with Fries | 7

    • PB & J with Fruit | 7

    Includes choice of juice, milk or fountain soda, freshly squeezed OJ (+1) 

    Email Signup

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thank you for signing up for email updates!